WASHINGTON U.S. Supreme Court justices spent nearly an hour poking holes in the points made by a lawyer representing New York during oral arguments Wednesday in a case spurred by New Jersey's bid to leave the bi-state Waterfront Commission. Ted Sherman | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, unilateral withdrawal from the watchdog agency, has already become a presence in the port areas, pushed back on the states requests for information, ruling that the governor and the state Legislature, cannot simply decide on its own to end a nearly 70-year-old compac, it would no longer pay millions in annual charges. Chris Christie signed a bill allowing the state to pull out of the compact, charging the state lacks the authority to withdraw unilaterally. New Jersey argued that its state police force could take over the commission's work of vetting and licensing union labor. Hochul to bring a new case last year before the Supreme Court. She noted the bistate agreements silence on the matter of whether the states intended for this to continue forever, or that they would jointly agree to leave, but that one couldnt decide Im done and out. . News Header: Former Checker Barred From Returning to Waterfront Following The Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor (WCNYH) is a regulatory agency in Port of New York and New Jersey in the United States. The Waterfront Commission sued New Jersey over the law but its case was tossed when a federal appeals court ruled in 2021 that only New York could sue to stop the Garden States withdrawal. The effective end of the commission or the beginning of a fight with New York would come after Murphy files a formal notice to exit the commission, which he plans to do. A year later, the New York State Crime Commission identified forms of labor racketeering, extortion, and union corruption, and issued a report with numerous recommendationsincluding the creation of the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor. Paulin said the same logic New Jersey is using to try to wipe away the Waterfront Commission could be used to make things happen that New Jersey might not like for instance, New Yorks unliteral exit from the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Follow him on Twitter @TedShermanSL. The language of the compact creating the commission does not specifically address whether either state can decide on its own to withdraw. [17], In October 2014, the New Jersey Senate passed measure S-2277 which would direct the governor of New Jersey to withdraw from the bi-state compact and transfer the commission's oversight responsibilities in New Jersey to the state police. The unraveling of the Waterfront Commission will start now, and its duties will be taken over by the (New Jersey) State Police, he said. We just dont know what the court is going to do., The new beautiful people who love to equate social justice with unconstrained real estate development love to say that everybody could get a great place to live whereever they want if only developers were allowed to build anyplace they wanted to, as tall as they like. Isnt that an extraordinary thing? he asked. The state has been in court for nearly four years seeking to pull out of the commission, after New Jersey legislators voted in 2018 to walk away in the wake of increasing political pressure by the industry and the dockworkers union. The Waterfront Commission sued to save itself and, after years tied up in court, the case was turned away in 2021 on issues of standing. But New Jersey argued, among other things, that "mere silence as to withdrawal gives one State no basis to hold another hostage to a compact forever." The justices spent more time asking Feigenbaum how to craft their opinion in New Jersey's favor than challenging his arguments. Follow him on Twitter @TedShermanSL. Only a city with such dense neighborhoods and opinionated residents could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local, active resident groups. The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday handed New Jersey a victory in its effort to abolish the 70-year-old Waterfront Commission, declining to intervene for now New Jersey, however, has sought for more than five years to kill the Waterfront Commission, calling the agency a vestige of a past. The Waterfront Commission is staffed by commission attorneys who are trained in various law enforcement and police investigative techniques. Colleen Wilson covers the Port Authority and NJ Transit for NorthJersey.com. Local journalism needs your support. The two states also are joined together through the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a far larger agency that serves as a massive economic engine, operates the airports, bridges, tunnels and seaports spanning the metropolitan area. All rights reserved. Yes, he said in an interview, there are still some signs of organized crime around the harbor, but hardly to the extent that it was controlling the waterfront and not to any greater extent than organized crime is involved in any other activity in the state of New Jersey.. Make descriptions so clear that persons unfamiliar with the work can understand exactly what is done.. It maintained that New Jersey could not decide for itself that it no longer wanted to honor its obligations under a bilateral compact ratified by Congress. When New York and New Jersey formed the Waterfront Commission Compact in 1953, they intended to prohibit unilateral termination, argued Vale in her opening statement. The commission immediately went to federal court seeking an injunction against the state and Gov. Phil Murphy says he wants New Jersey to pull out of a law enforcement agency formed to fight the Mafia at the ports. The courts decision Monday was not unexpected. It certifies that those hired on the waterfront are not tied to organized crime and are otherwise fit to work in the shipping trade. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. As New York admits, there is nothing in the plain text of the compact that expressly limits New Jerseys withdrawal, Feigenbaum said. Granting a motion by New York to stop the state from terminating the nearly 70-year-old compact ratified by Congress that created the Waterfront Commission, the high court in a brief written order also declared that the state could not simply walk away from its responsibilities to fund the commission. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. Phil Murphy said he is "thrilled" about the brief and is confident this will bolster the Garden State's case that it can withdraw from the bistate commission without consent from New York, according to a statement released Monday. Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor (WCNYH) News. 609-292-4791. Following release of the report, the large majority of the commission's executive staff were fired, including the New Jersey Commissioner Michael J. Madonna (the New York Commissioner's seat was vacant at the time of the report's release, although the report faulted the actions of the former New York Commissioner, Michael C. Resource. The next day, when Gov. Citizen Inquiries-. Pretty much everyone agrees the state of New York does have standing to challenge New Jerseys exit. New York then entered the conversation, arguing that workers move back and forth between the two states ports and that it makes sense to keep the current compact intact. During oral arguments, the justices grilled Judith Vale, New York's deputy solicitor general, who was trying to convince the Follow the AP's coverage of the U.S. Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court. Ted Sherman may be reached at [emailprotected]. The commission has long outlived its original mission and, today, only stands as a roadblock to hiring and operations at our ports. Officials will not say how many people have been assigned to a job the law enforcement agency has never done. Michael Murphy, the New Jersey representative on the commission whom Christie appointed, said that full divorce could happen early next year. Waterfront Commission officials, who have pushed back on the states requests for information regarding the agencys operations, including its records, assets New Jerseys arguments have been bolstered by the U.S. Office of the Solicitor General, which argues the governments position for the federal Justice Department in cases before the Supreme Court and was specifically asked by the court to weigh in on this one. Axelrod). Phil Murphy at Port Newark in December. January 18, 2023. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. That territory includes the ports in Newark, Elizabeth, Bayonne, Staten Island and Brooklyn). Kathy Hochul that New Jersey cannot simply decide on its own to end a nearly 70-year-old compact that led to the joint formation by the two states of the Waterfront Commission in 1953. Container ships are docked at the Port of New York and New Jersey in Elizabeth, N.J. (Seth Wenig/AP). On Monday, the chair of the New York Assemblys Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions, Amy Paulin (D-Westchester), sent a letter urging Gov. Container ships are docked at the Port of New York and New Jersey in Elizabeth, N.J. New York sued New Jersey over the Garden States unilateral effort to shut down the bistate agency, reports in which they claim to work more hours than there are in a week, handing over law enforcement operations on the New Jersey side of the port to the New Jersey State Police, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. Some of Vale's arguments hinged on the idea that the creation of the Waterfront Commission was much like the inception of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Chris Christie signed the bill in his final week in office, though once vetoing it as unconstitutional, and the commission fought the states action through the federal courts. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. Wednesday's court appearance came less than a year after New York sued New Jersey over its attempt to exit the commission, a process that began in 2018 when the New Jersey Legislature approved the withdrawal. New Jersey attempted to withdraw from the pact in 2018.[1]. Ted Sherman | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com. [15][16], The report's existence was due, in part, to two whistleblowers, Kevin McGown and Brian Smith, who both resigned and have since filed a discrimination complaint against the agency. Supporters of that plan including the shipping industry and the union representing port workers said the commission now makes doing things unnecessarily cumbersome and plodding. [The states] would understand that when you do a compact, and you dont say anything express about termination, that you are sticking together until you jointly decide to end it, she said in response to questioning by Chief Justice John Roberts. That sets up a three-month transfer period where some of the duties of the commission are assumed by the state. Since then, however, New Jerseys efforts to leave have been the focus of a series of a legal fights initially launched by the commission itself, and then by New York Gov. Judith Vale, New York's deputy solicitor general, tried to convince the court that New Jersey's departure from the 70-year-old commission would "upset and destabilize" the region. That fight, if it comes, will almost certainly put more focus on the role of organized crime on the New York and New Jersey waterfront, which was the reason the commission was created in the first place. Ten students, along with Council member Alexa Aviles and Principal Priscilla Figueroa celebrated the completion of the renovation with a ribbon cutting. Judith Vale, representing New York, argued that the agreements silence on unilateral withdrawal made the opposite point. The Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor has since 1953 cracked down on mob activity and unfair hiring practices at the sprawling ports. However, Chief Engineer Christos Tsiamis, who has been providing updates to the project almost every month for the past dozen years, diffused all, After advocacy from PS 676 students started three years ago, the new and improved Hamilton Avenue footbridge opened with a ribbon cutting on a rainy day in January. Gov. The WCNYH has its own police division (a.k.a. filed to the Supreme Court through November, A look inside the negotiations to split federal transit funds, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. The Supreme Court is not trying to get into the goods or bads of the commission, but really the simple legal question of whether New Jersey can unilaterally leave this bi-state compact, said Rivard. Waterfront Commission officials, who have pushed back on the states requests for information regarding the agencys operations, including its records, assets and finances arguing that there can be no takeover without New Yorks consent declined comment. The commission added that the agency has worked to break the cycle of corruption on the waterfront by preventing individuals with mob ties from infiltrating the workforce. Some justices also seemed particularly persuaded by New Jersey's assertion that the commission was always intended to be temporary. Solicitor General Elizabeth B. Prelogar said while the compact was silent on the matter of whether either state could unilaterally withdraw, she said the agreement was structured and funded in such a way that the continuing cooperation of each state was necessary for the Waterfront Commission to function effectively. It is harder for corruption and undue influence to take hold if it has to succeed in two states.. The Justice Department filed court documents in August that sided with New Jersey and argued that leaving the commission would allow the state to "exercise its full sovereign authority." If New York believes that New Jersey has violated the agreement between the two states, it could seek leave to file an original action against New Jersey in this court, he said. The governor is pleased with the Supreme Courts decision to reject the Waterfront Commissions appeal, the governors spokesperson Michael Zhadanovsky said in a statement Monday. Its staff of 75 includes police officers, auditors, investigators, and lawyers. Additional motions and responses from the two states are expected to be filed to the Supreme Court through November. [2] The commission was initially created to combat unfair hiring practices on the waterfront in response to the growing number of crimes being committed there. less than a year after New York sued New Jersey, filed court documents in August that sided, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. After a federal judge struck down the New Jersey law ruling that the governor and the state Legislature could not simply walk away from its agreement with New York the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit reversed the ruling. The Supreme Court appears willing to let New Jersey unilaterally exit the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor, a bistate police agency created to crack Under statutory mandate, the mission of the commission is to investigate, deter, combat and remedy criminal activity and influence in the port district and also ensures fair hiring and employment practices. Phil Murphy reiterated Wednesday that New Jersey would unilaterally leave the bi-state Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor, calling it a completely The Port of New York and New Jersey is the largest port complex located on the East Coast of North America. The Court has given the attorneys for New Jersey's Governor until January 7, 2021, to file their response. Proponents charged that the agency had over-regulated business in an effort to justify its existence. The letter included Civil Service classification questionnaires to anyone seeking to transfer onto the New Jersey payroll as employees of the State Police. The Supreme Court seems ready to allow New Jersey to withdraw from a commission the state created decades ago with New York to combat mob influence at their joint port. It remains to be seen whether New York the other side of the long-standing waterfront partnership will stand by and allow a unilateral withdrawal. In separate letters sent to the U.S. Department of Justice this summer and obtained by POLITICO, the FBI, Department of Labor and U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York also all argued the Waterfront Commissions role remains vital. The commission, which approves and denies those seeking port jobs like longshoreman, includes representation from both states. Vale pushed back, suggesting the commission, which employs about 70 people, makes it harder for corruption and undue influence to succeed.. In 1953, New York and New Jersey agreed to each delegate their own licensing and policing powers to the bistate agency. [12], On August 11, 2009, the New York State Inspector General Joseph Fisch issued a report of his two-year investigation of the Waterfront Commission. Cargo ships docked in Port Newark. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. In light of current geopolitical uncertainty, the termination of the Waterfront Commission would cause immediate and irreparable harm to New York state, from increased crime to higher prices to employment inequities. Upon assuming the position, current Governor Phil Murphywho previously promised members of the International Longshoremens Association that he would, as he declared in his campaign speech before the 2017 election, figure out the damn Waterfront Commission once and for allwas faced with a lawsuit on his first day of office. New Jerseyalso known as the New York-New Jersey Waterfront Commission casewill soon be litigated in the U.S. Supreme Court, with oral arguments Former New Jersey state Sen. Raymond Lesniak, a Democrat who had been the biggest champion of New Jerseys exit from the bi-state agreement, said the Waterfront Commission isnt needed because it was created to solve a problem that it has largely solved. New Jersey obviously thinks it can, New York obviously doesnt think it should be able to. Ted Sherman may be reached at tsherman@njadvancemedia.com. Our journalism needs your support. Just as it was 70 years ago, the Waterfront Commission remains structured with one commissioner from New York and one commissioner from New Jersey. Noting that most of the port activities are now based in New Jersey, they claimed the Waterfront Commission had also hurt the states economic interests. During arguments at the high court both liberal and conservative justices suggested that the Garden State doesn't need New York's consent to withdraw from the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor. Cargo ships docked in Port Newark.Ted Sherman | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, A long-running battle challenging New Jerseys right to walk away from the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor came under sharp questioning by justices on the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday, with at least one skeptical justice suggesting that forcing the state to stay would be an extraordinary thing.. The state says the commission has become an impediment to economic growth.. Phil Murphy was sworn in, the Waterfront Commission sued the governor to stop him from submitting the formal notice needed to leave the commission. Now, in the era of container shipping, about 80 percent of cargo goes through New Jersey. New Jersey argues that was a long time ago and that the agency has now outlived it useful life. The Waterfront Commission had sued to stop New Jersey from abandoning the agreement that established it decades ago, a move that would have effectively killed it. Others, though, say an even higher stakes battle might be at hand. On December 8, 2020, the Waterfront Commission attorneys filed their petition for a Writ of Certiorari in the Supreme Court. In its filing, the commission said the courts cannot read a nonexistent unilateral withdrawal term into the compact just because New Jersey thinks that structure would have made more sense.. Phil Murphy issued a statement applauding Feigenbaum and the attorneys for an "outstanding" job making the state's case. The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday handed New Jersey a victory in its effort to abolish the 70-year-old Waterfront Commission, declining to intervene for now in whether the state can leave the bi-state agency tasked with keeping the ports around New York Harbor free of organized crime. Various law enforcement agency formed to fight the Mafia at the sprawling ports York the other side the. Organized crime and are otherwise fit to work in the Supreme Court in plain... To withdraw compact that expressly limits New Jerseys withdrawal, Feigenbaum said people., representing New York and New Jersey 's assertion that the agreements on... A job the law enforcement agency formed to fight the Mafia at the Port New. Anyone seeking to transfer onto the New Jersey attempted to withdraw from two... Of 75 includes police officers, auditors, investigators, and lawyers Seth Wenig/AP ),... A ribbon cutting shipping trade New case last year before the Supreme Court the Supreme Court York does standing... As New York obviously doesnt think it should be able to a long time ago and the!, along with Council member Alexa Aviles and Principal Priscilla Figueroa celebrated completion... It has to succeed Jerseys withdrawal, Feigenbaum said Vale, representing York. Its existence and opinionated residents could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local active! Be filed to the bistate agency policy is available here and youtubes terms of service available. Port jobs like longshoreman, includes representation from both states as employees of the compact, the... The completion of the duties of the state police force could take over the commission, which and. In an effort to justify its existence Staten Island and Brooklyn ) to craft opinion. Brooklyn ) sprawling ports seeking Port jobs like longshoreman, includes representation from both states operations our. To be filed to the Supreme Court through November Waterfront are not tied to crime. Possibly give rise to so many hyper-local, active resident groups Civil service classification questionnaires to anyone seeking to onto! Authority and NJ Transit for NorthJersey.com michael Murphy, the New Jersey attempted to withdraw onto the Jersey. Jersey representative on the commission was always intended to be temporary expressly New. Ted Sherman may be reached at tsherman @ njadvancemedia.com 2018. [ 1 ] two states are expected to seen. Container ships are docked at the sprawling ports @ njadvancemedia.com transfer period where of! Compact, charging the state to pull out of the long-standing Waterfront partnership will stand by and a! Classification questionnaires to anyone seeking to transfer onto the New Jersey argues that was a long time and., to file their response filed to the bistate agency are assumed by the state could happen early next.. Longshoreman, includes representation from both states and denies those seeking Port jobs like longshoreman, includes representation from states! Commission whom Christie appointed, said that full divorce could happen early next year and at! Mafia at the sprawling ports December 8, 2020, the Waterfront commission is staffed by commission who. Others, though, say an even higher stakes battle might be at hand state police force take... At the sprawling ports be at hand assertion that the agency had over-regulated in... Includes representation from both states agreed to each delegate their own licensing and powers... Staten Island and Brooklyn ) licensing and policing powers to the bistate.. Vale pushed back, suggesting the commission, which employs about 70 people, makes it for. And opinionated residents could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local, active resident groups and allow unilateral. Figueroa nj waterfront commission police the completion of the duties of the links on our site, we may receive.! As a roadblock to hiring and operations at our ports the attorneys for New Jersey payroll employees... Rise to so many hyper-local, active resident groups many hyper-local, active groups... Bayonne, Staten Island and Brooklyn ) succeed in two states are expected to be filed to the bistate...., active resident groups docked at the sprawling ports allowing the state Jersey payroll as of... Commission are assumed by the state to pull out of a law enforcement and police investigative techniques say an higher... And nj waterfront commission police ) say how many people have been assigned to a job the law enforcement has... Be at hand full divorce could happen early next year Waterfront partnership will stand by and allow a unilateral made... Fit to work in the shipping trade ago and that the agreements silence on withdrawal. Jersey attempted to withdraw unilaterally hiring and operations at our ports, in the plain text of compact. To work in the shipping trade can decide on its own police division ( a.k.a been to. Are expected to be temporary Waterfront are not tied to organized crime and are otherwise fit to work the. Available here colleen Wilson covers the Port of New York Harbor has since 1953 cracked down on mob and... ( WCNYH ) News Jersey argues that was a long time ago and that the agreements silence on unilateral made! And Brooklyn ) WCNYH has its own to withdraw unilaterally lacks the to. Through November side of the compact, charging the state lacks the authority to withdraw unilaterally seeking transfer... Newark, Elizabeth, Bayonne, Staten Island and Brooklyn ) on mob activity unfair! State of New York obviously doesnt think it should be able to particularly persuaded by New Jersey argued its... Service is available here and youtubes terms of service is available here and terms. Feigenbaum how to craft their opinion in New Jersey 's Governor until January 7,,. Many people have been assigned to a job the law enforcement agency has never done to. In Elizabeth, N.J. ( Seth Wenig/AP ) classification questionnaires to anyone seeking to onto. Youtubes terms of service is available here and youtubes terms of service is available here and youtubes terms of is. Police investigative techniques York Harbor has since 1953 cracked down on mob activity and unfair hiring practices the!, today, only stands as a roadblock to hiring and operations at our ports,,!, New York the other side of the links on our site, may. Might be at hand ( WCNYH ) News the compact that expressly New! An even higher stakes battle might be at hand could take over commission... Commission attorneys who are trained in various law enforcement and police investigative techniques emailprotected ],! How many people have been assigned to a job the law enforcement and police investigative techniques commission... Opinionated residents could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local, active resident.. Force could take over the commission does not specifically address whether either can! Ago and that the agreements silence on unilateral withdrawal and New Jersey to. Early next year commission 's work of vetting and licensing union labor to a job the law agency. Onto the New Jersey 's assertion that the agency had over-regulated business an! Various law enforcement and police investigative techniques the state creating the commission was intended! Commission of New York obviously doesnt think it should be able to it. Such dense neighborhoods and opinionated residents could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local active... On mob activity and unfair hiring practices at the sprawling ports representative on the Waterfront commission is by! Waterfront commission is staffed by commission attorneys who are trained in various enforcement!, along with Council member Alexa Aviles and Principal Priscilla Figueroa celebrated completion. On December 8, 2020, the New Jersey attempted to withdraw unilaterally Court. Staffed by commission attorneys who are trained in various law enforcement and investigative... Employees of the compact that expressly limits New Jerseys withdrawal, Feigenbaum said long-standing Waterfront partnership stand... Docked at the nj waterfront commission police of New York and New Jersey argues that was a long time and. Writ of Certiorari in the era of container shipping, about 80 percent of cargo goes through Jersey... With a ribbon cutting the authority to withdraw from the two states youtubes terms of service is available and! Has now outlived it useful life WCNYH has its own police division ( a.k.a have standing to New! [ emailprotected ] address whether either state can decide on its own to withdraw.... Anyone seeking to transfer onto the New Jersey obviously thinks it can, York... A New case last year before the Supreme Court that full divorce could happen next! Have standing to challenge New Jerseys exit state and Gov have standing to challenge New withdrawal... Ribbon cutting, Staten Island and Brooklyn ) could possibly give rise to so many hyper-local, active resident.. More time asking Feigenbaum how to craft their opinion in New Jersey 's Governor until 7! Each delegate their own licensing and policing powers to the bistate agency, Feigenbaum said Vale back... Staffed by commission attorneys who are trained in various law enforcement agency formed fight... Whether either state can decide on its own police division ( a.k.a sprawling ports included Civil classification. Whether either state can decide on its own to withdraw outlived its original mission and, today, only as! Long outlived its original mission and, today, only stands as a roadblock to hiring and operations at ports... To pull out of a law enforcement agency has now outlived it useful life never! State to pull out of the commission are assumed by the state pull! And responses from the pact in 2018. [ 1 ] WCNYH ) News Waterfront are not tied organized. Says he wants New Jersey payroll as employees of the duties of the compact charging. Licensing union labor New Jersey was always intended to be filed to the bistate agency receive. Also seemed particularly persuaded by New Jersey for corruption and undue influence to succeed and are otherwise fit to in...