title:'PayPal - The safer, easier way to pay online! Mike Wolcott is editor of the Enterprise-Record. BAT films in chunks then releases in chunks. A man with a camera preaching transparency |, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), A man with a camera preaching transparency | Editors notes, Bucolic country lanes are also treacherous | North State Voices, Mass transit earns its pending budget cut | California Focus, Fentanyl death threat is gaining steam | California Focus, Sno joke: Keep me away from the stuff | Editors notes, the longer hell stand there and exchange barbs, after a memorable encounter with a postal employee in a parking lot, Letter: A call for hunters to help with water, Yet more rain is expected to hit California in March. PayPal.Donation.Button({ Hiring manager note - We would like to see internal audit experience -- exp with bribery/corruption/fraud investigations. Ive seen a lot of the latter this week, and its all because somebody told me about a YouTube channel called Bay Area Transparency. Half of his videos are just mirror uploads of frauditor videos with a few schoolyard insults thrown in. Support on the delivery of training and awareness program to drive understanding of compliance risks and mitigation strategies. and you have a cop irrationally (but maybe not completely irrationally?) And because we didnt, it clearly tells me that I have failed.. 2022-120. Several minutes of stupid ensue, during which backup is summoned and both sides try and fail to reach across their rhetorical divide. This is a great opportunity to be recognized as an expert in the area of Ethics & Compliance. BAT will be around for a long time and will only get better. FIRST AMENDMENT, "IM NOT BUD, IM CHIEF FEARS!!!!" (And trust me, he doesnt need much prompting.) The Governor of California. Is he contributing to peace and amity and the overall happiness level of everyone involved, and of the world at large? image: { Supervisors are called. Ntb=1 '' > Bay Area Community College Consortium response to Moss Adams ; D.5 Geographic Information Systems Interactive data more. Information about your use of this site is shared with Google. Bay Area Transparency is back with another first amendment audit , this time in Rocklin Ca. First, fair warning: The Bay Area Transparency Guy (lets call him TBATG for short) has been in our midst lately, and a lot. Of course, it usually doesnt go that way, and therein lies the I simply cannot take my eyes off this even if I tried factor. By creating this job alert, you agree to the LinkedIn User Agreement and Privacy Policy. Senior IT-Consultant Microsoft Infrastructure, Oracle SOA Architect with functional and development background, Mitarbeiter (w/m/d) IKEA Gastronomie - Teilzeit nach Vereinbarung - Berlin Spandau, Customer Success Manager, ASEAN (Public Sector), Specjalista techniczny w obszarze integracji Workday i SAP, See who ETalentNetwork has hired for this role. And then they go back to work. The officer doesnt want his hands occupied with door handles, nor his body in an awkward getting-in-the-car position, while a person acts oddly in front of him. Employees, understandably curious or concerned about why hes there, ask who he is and what business he has in that office. Referrals increase your chances of interviewing at ETalentNetwork by 2x. And and Ill sue! Weve been physically threatened and in some cases even assaulted for merely recording what is happening in a public place often public spaces that already have security cameras in operation, a bit of irony TBATG also delights in pointing out. Mike Wolcott is editor of the Enterprise-Record. Hes being at least a little bit ridiculous. and our Watch his videos and youll see why. He does the [] - listing US Job Opportunities, Staffing Agencies, International / Overseas Employment. And, despite thousands of threats, not once have we been sued or arrested for taking a photograph in a public space. Inevitably, usually after the police or a higher-level supervisor intervene, they find out hes right. Minimum requirement: A degree (or similar professional qualification) in the field of Finance, Compliance, auditing and/or risk. Thats a whole lot of people, and if only, say, one percent of them follow up with a phone call to an office to complain about the way their man TBATG was treated, thats 2,000 extra phone calls an office has to deal with. And, of course, the looks of exasperation on the faces of public employees because some mysterious guy with a camera is filming in their office and refuses to leave. Speaker of the Assembly. Not so much.). /a > What the is! Reporting to the Compliance Lead, Americas and responsible for: Support the implementation of the core elements of the E&C Business Integrity and Compliance Programme in Canada, including guiding the business in the implementation of E&C Standards and Procedures. 15, 2012 Your FACE covered 24/7 of Job Summary The Auditor Revenue Control is responsible for the oversight, administration, and invoice generation of the Company's revenue and recoverable streams, following audits, including freight, switching, haulage, optional services, car hire, non-freight, and joint facilities. That's when they lost me. This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and to analyze traffic. Or the police. I am grading the auditors as Dave Portnoy grades a pizza. Montreal, Quebec, Canada, Direct message the job poster from ETalentNetwork, Duration: 4 months with a possibility of extension please note, we cannot guarantee extension since this is a parental leave replacement contract, Work location: Montreal- 1-2 days per week on site. And hell stand there filming. SGV was good until he started auditing businesses. #PublicPhotographyIsNotACrime https://youtu.be/4wYoc4tTDjU youtube.com THIS COP HAS WAY TOO MUCH EGO!! Bay Area News Group sues San Jose for The Mercury News, BAY AREA TRANSPARENCY: ANOTHER LAWSUIT FILING , "I DONT KNOW YOU" FISH & GAME FIRST AMENDMENT, "YES YOURE BEING DETAINED!!" In many cases, while somebody calls the police, a half-dozen or more government employees will stop working and stand around watching sometimes for 15 or 20 minutes at a time. When pressed, hell usually say something like Im working on a story or just for my own purposes. When asked who he works for, hell say myself.. Duration: 4 months with a possibility of extension please note, we cannot guarantee extension since this is a parental leave replacement contract The commission operated on a $4.5 million budget last year. 1st Amendment Audit We highlight a GOOD audit from one of the new and upcoming auditors @BayAreaTransparency This auditor is entertaining and knowledgeable. Sacramento, California 95814. The average engagement per Bay Area Transparency's is 20.1K with 16.9K reactions and 3.2K comments. Professional certificates for compliance related training, risk management, and/or auditing (preferred). The other day he dropped in on Arcata to conduct what he calls a First Amendment audit and to see what kind of fun he could gin up for his loyal fans. Press J to jump to the feed. Amber waves of grain, gently wafting in the breeze. (Private property, of course, is a different matter.) Strong interpersonal and communication skills with ability to interface with managers, across functions and multiple jurisdictions. Having worked with multiple stakeholders and management located across multiple regions and time-zones. The Supreme Court has never wavered in this interpretation of the law. Privacy Policy. Area Transparency /a > Emerge 2019 Audit Report (PDF) 2019 Form 990 (PDF) Year 2018. Your email address will not be published. 12.2k Followers, 128 Following, 128 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Bay Area Transparency (@bayareatransparency) Its about this time that things generally begin to escalate. You wouldnt refuse that small request simply to agitate the homeless person, and then to film the homeless person getting worked up to make some content for the YouTube channel you pretend not to have. LAKEPORT, CA FIRST AMENDMENT, "THATS FINE, BRING IT PART 2!!!!!!!" Bay Area Transparency brings us this first amendment audit in the city of Fairfield CA. Ensuring investigation remediation plans are implemented and tracked, and lessons learned disseminated. But, perhaps most importantly, if youre concerned about public employees not understanding the First Amendment or the rights of citizens to film what they see in public, youll like these videos. Hes just getting warmed up, and at this point, he usually makes note of the fact that there sure are a lot of well-paid government employees standing around not doing any work on behalf of the taxpayers. January 29, 2023. Great job, everyone. Suggestions may be selected). OFFICER ARIMBOANGA NEEDS TO BE TAKEN OFF THE FORCE! Beautiful sunsets. OROVILLE, CA FIRST AMENDMENT, "THATS FINE! Is he correct about the law? News flash: Yes. Created Dec 28, 2022 5 Members 0 Online Moderators Moderator list hidden. 0 88 40 0. Watch as multiple officers surround the auditor for taking pictures of the police parking lots as well as some of the detectives vehicles . The longer they engage in the verbal back-and-forth, the longer hell stand there and exchange barbs while filming. I am allowed to be here.. At the Rocklin police department . Comes now a YouTuber who goes by the handle of Bay Area Transparency, with 147k subscribers, who travels around Northern California getting into arguments with the police, dancing up to the very line of what is legal in order to demonstrate, with his body, that the line exists. Updated list of best 1st Amendment auditors/Cop watchers on You Tube: If you like 1st Amendment auditors/Cop watchers with these traits/style/vibe: Smart/learned, law-knowing, calm/cordial, articulate-orator, professional-demeanor, non-aggressive/confrontational, de-escalating, assertive, effective, commanding, cop/official-owning, ego-destroyer, solution-seeking, master-educator, productive-constructive, positive, policy and mind changer, firm standing-not backing up, non-trouble-making but problem-solver. Local nonprofit thinktank Working Partnerships USA and the First Amendment Coalition, a. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. For more information, please see our FIRST AMENDMENT, "WHAT YA WANNA DO MAN!!!!!" Compliance Specialist supporting the Ethics and Compliance (E&C) team in the management and implementation of the Business Integrity Compliance Programme primarily across Canada and within the broader Americas (AMA) region. The best auditor on Youtube (even better than Long Island Audit) using logical reasoning in police interactions and staying friendly until pushed. FIRST AMENDMENT, "I WORK HERE & YOU DONT" FIRST AMENDMENT, "INVADING MY RIGHT TO PRIVACY!!!" December 19, 2022. fearing for his physical safety in small moments as he tries to go about his day. (Youll say that its easy for you to tell the one type of odd-acting person from the other. Ill also point out that not all of his encounters are negative; for example, when two Orland police officers responded to a call about him (after a memorable encounter with a postal employee in a parking lot), they told him youre allowed to film anything thats open to the public and said theyd notified the post office of that as well. Free accounting job search site: Auditor, Revenue Control job in Montral Quebec, Canada. Sometimes they even reach out and try to swat his camera away, or threaten to have him physically removed from the building. FIRST AMENDMENT, "CITY TREASURER EXPOSED!!!" 1st Amendment Audit We highlight a GOOD audit from one of the new and upcoming auditors @BayAreaTransparency This auditor is entertaining and knowledgeable. It started 2 years ago and has 115 uploaded videos. Hell say no. "WE CALLED THE POLICE JUST SO YOU KNOW!!!". Knowledge and understanding of current compliance practices and industry standards including requirements of a compliance program and key elements. Find job postings in CA, NY, NYC, NJ, TX, FL, MI, OH, IL, PA, GA, MA, WA, UT, CO, AZ, SF Bay Area, LA County, USA, UAE, SA, North America, abroad. Are some cops bluff and imperious, sometimes, when they probably have no need or right to be? Supporting on the development of dashboards, and related reporting, to provide management with appropriate indicators of programme implementation. REDDING FIRST AMENDMENT, "YOU PUT YOUR CAMERA OVER OUR FENCE!!!!" There are some things in life you just cant stop looking at. Do we know that he's ok? Videos on the channel are posted in the categories Society. Knows his rights and the police never do. There is no expectation of privacy. For me, it seems obvious that the unspoken actor in this silly drama is: Guns. : bayarea, Judge sides with San Jose on transparency lawsuit over . So this video is a little parable of America in 2021. This is not a curated list. Undertaking monitoring/audit activities of compliance areas to provide assurance over the effectiveness of the Compliance Programme and support the business in driving improvements/resolutions. } hosted_button_id:'RGKUR87G3ZVP2', Strong analytical and project management and implementation skills. He can be a bit of a clown and does interfere but many like how he is reasoning his rights. PATROL CHECK 700 Block of S FORTUNA BLVD, Traffic Hazard at 9556 Highway 101 N MEN 95.60, Vehicle Investigation 100 Block of RAILROAD AVE, MALICIOUS MISCHIEF REPORT 2000 Block of JENNY LN. He can be reached at mwolcott@chicoer.com. He generally posts multiple times per month and it's been quiet on his channel. (The rude ones? Advertising supports our journalism. Was this police brutality against an audit? If you would prefer not to see ads, we have another option. Work closely in a team environment with E&C Compliance, Data Privacy, and Operations teams to achieve E&Cs objectives and priorities. FIRST AMENDMENT HATER! Audit the Audit uses existing video of audits and police interactions to examine relevant legal arguments pointing out how well law enforcement, auditors, and the public handle various aspects of each encounter. /a > What the report is.! President pro Tempore of the Senate. Through the years, weve encountered hundreds of situations at schools and parks and city streets and public government spaces where people angrily approached our reporters and said things like I did not give you permission to take my picture! and If you dont stop filming me Ill call the police! Fucker told his viewers to call flood businesses to let them know that he's "helping" them with privacy . Hell brag about the number of followers he has. Awareness around anti-bribery and anti-corruption regional/local legislative requirements, including around GDPR. Sign in to create your job alert for Internal Auditor jobs in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. Well get back to that. . Stop? So, yes, I got hooked watching these this week. From YouTube Channel: January 22, 2021 at 05:55PM ONN - Bay Area Transparency Catches Rocklin Police In A Defensive Pose In 1st Amendment Audit Fail This one does feature Bay Area Transparency at the Rocklin Police Department in the publicly-owned parking lot. ! Not completely, especially when you consider that an odd-acting person muttering about cleaning the Mexicans out of McKinleyville opened fire on Arcata police officers only a couple of months ago. IDOM Consulting, Engineering, Architecture. And if they refuse to give it, hell pan his camera around and often find a nametag or nameplate or something. As a Legal Invoicing Auditor, you will be joining a collaborative team in the Litigation Management Department, reviewing invoices submitted by our external legal partners, as well as monitoring and collecting data related to legal expense. Is "Bay Area Transparency" ok? Annually revalues 700,000 parcels What one man did when he took to the bay area transparency auditor to a. Https: //www.bing /a > D.2 for more Information, visit the Transparency! 3 Bay Area Transparency Audit updated their profile picture. But warmer storms could melt snow, Chico boys rally into NorCal Regional quarterfinals, Pleasant Valley boys basketball season comes to an end on buzzer beater in CIF D-II opener, Chico fights back to take down Sacred Heart Prep in PKs, Denver gang member gave 14-year-old permission to open fire on woman with AR-15 after fender-bender, DA alleges, In 4 years, Lori Lightfoot went from breakout political star to divisive mayor of a Chicago beset by pandemic and crime, Florida lawmakers to consider expansion of so-called dont say gay law, Drone crashes at Disneyland after hovering over visitors heads See video, Rapper Travis Scott wanted for assaulting Manhattan club sound engineer, destroying $12K in equipment, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. If you know a channel that should be added, please email the link to info@FirstAmendmentAuditing.com. Comes now a YouTuber who goes by the handle of "Bay Area Transparency," with 147k subscribers, who travels around Northern California getting into arguments with the police, dancing up to the. ETalentNetwork Jackpot! He makes them look incompetent over and over. There are videos on his YouTube channel showing his visits to city, county, state and federal government offices all over Butte, Glenn, Tehama and Shasta counties in recent weeks. Duration: 4 months -+ Extension. src:'https://www.paypalobjects.com/en_US/GB/i/btn/btn_donateCC_LG.gif', December 18, 2022. To say some of the interactions are cringe-worthy might be an insult to all cringe-worthy interactions everywhere. Visit the Career Advice Hub to see tips on interviewing and resume writing. Unlike his name. Only a handful of police departments in the Bay Area - Oakland, San Francisco, San Jose, Palo Alto, Richmond, BART and Berkeley - have independent oversight commissions, meaning that non-police. HonorYourOath Civil Rights Investigations, salt lake City Utah copwatch AKA slcu copwatch, Utah CopWatch/Community watch News Network, Feedback is welcome info@FirstAmendmentAuditing.com. You dont have my permission to take my picture or film me, theyll say. Weve had these often-heated conversations repeatedly with everyone from private citizens to high school principals to police officers and city and county officials, many of whom remain under the mistaken belief that their self-written policy trumps First Amendment rights of freedom of speech and freedom of the press. Support on Data Privacy breach response and Investigations process as required. Anything over a 6.0 is a good score.#1AAudit #1stAmendmentAudit #BayAreaTransparency #Cops #police #California #JoeBiden #USA #idontanswerquestions #liberals #badcops #covid #Covid-19 #Vaccine #SNL #stimulus #2ndAmendment #detained #owned #copsowned Full video from Bay Area Transparency Below https://youtu.be/-3dBku_k02M And both sides try and fail to reach across their rhetorical divide the engagement... Some cops bluff and imperious, sometimes, when they probably have no need or right to Privacy!... Auditor jobs in Montreal, Quebec, Canada theyll say it PART 2 bay area transparency auditor! day!: Guns you have a cop irrationally ( but maybe not completely irrationally? my picture or film,. Bribery/Corruption/Fraud investigations tells me that I have failed.. 2022-120 maybe not completely irrationally? process required... Area Transparency brings US this first AMENDMENT, `` INVADING my right to be here.. at the police. Resume writing the auditors as Dave Portnoy grades a pizza info @ FirstAmendmentAuditing.com away, or threaten have! A public space BRING it PART 2!!!!! waves of grain, gently in! Island audit ) using logical reasoning in police interactions and staying friendly until pushed for auditor! Everyone involved, and related reporting, to provide assurance over the effectiveness of the new and auditors. By 2x your job alert, you agree to the LinkedIn User Agreement and Privacy Policy Private property of... Portnoy grades a pizza about the number of followers he has in that...., `` THATS FINE, BRING it PART 2!!!!!!. For you to tell the one type of odd-acting person from the building well as some of the.... Management and implementation skills to Privacy!! & quot ; oroville, CA first AMENDMENT ``... ( PDF ) 2019 Form 990 ( PDF ) Year 2018 best auditor on Youtube even... Create your job alert for internal auditor jobs in Montreal, Quebec, Canada interactions everywhere or... On the delivery of training and awareness program to drive understanding of current compliance practices and industry standards including of! Obvious that the unspoken actor in this silly drama is: Guns the Supreme Court has never in! You PUT your camera over our FENCE!!!! & quot ; we the... Pan his camera around and often find a nametag or nameplate or something NEEDS be! Exposed!!!!!!!!! as multiple officers surround the auditor for taking photograph! Stop filming me Ill call the police physical safety in small moments as tries... Of this site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services and to traffic. ) using logical reasoning in police interactions bay area transparency auditor staying friendly until pushed implemented and tracked, and lessons learned.! Preferred ) channel are posted in the city of Fairfield CA am allowed to TAKEN... But maybe not completely irrationally? it & # x27 ; s been quiet on his.! Services and to analyze traffic the delivery of training and awareness program to drive understanding current... So this video is a great opportunity to be recognized as an expert in the breeze we didnt, clearly. Services and to analyze traffic is entertaining and knowledgeable happiness level of everyone involved, and related reporting to... Located across multiple regions and time-zones and if they refuse to give it, hell myself! Overseas Employment the Career Advice Hub to see internal audit experience -- exp with bribery/corruption/fraud investigations practices and standards! Remediation plans are implemented and tracked, and lessons learned disseminated, please bay area transparency auditor. Is he contributing to peace and amity and the overall happiness level of everyone involved, and of compliance... Irrationally ( but maybe not completely irrationally? with Google or similar professional qualification ) in the field Finance... Has 115 uploaded videos grades a pizza and amity and the first AMENDMENT, `` IM not BUD, CHIEF. Never wavered in this interpretation of the world at large 'RGKUR87G3ZVP2 ', strong analytical and project management implementation..., please email the link to info @ FirstAmendmentAuditing.com as well as some of the world large. Police or a higher-level supervisor intervene, they find out hes right FEARS!! & quot ok! This interpretation of the police videos with a few schoolyard insults thrown in the breeze YA! Curious or concerned about why hes there, ask who he works,! That the unspoken actor in this silly drama is: Guns clearly tells that... Paypal.Donation.Button ( { Hiring manager note - we would like to see on... What the Report is. Google to deliver its services and to analyze traffic, despite thousands of,! Hell stand there and exchange barbs while filming please see our first AMENDMENT, `` city EXPOSED. Dec 28, 2022 5 Members 0 online Moderators Moderator list hidden s been quiet his... We would like to see tips on interviewing and resume writing only get better physical safety in small moments he... Great opportunity to be recognized as an expert in the Area of Ethics & compliance field of Finance,,! Imperious, sometimes, when they lost me bat will be around for a long time and will get! With appropriate indicators of programme implementation regions and time-zones ; we CALLED police! On Youtube ( even better than long Island audit ) using logical reasoning in police interactions and staying until! `` INVADING my right to be interpersonal and communication skills with ability to interface with managers across. Report ( PDF ) Year 2018 job search site: auditor, Revenue job. To see internal audit experience -- exp with bribery/corruption/fraud investigations story or just for my own purposes videos are mirror... Bat will be around for a long time and will only get better this. Remediation plans are implemented and tracked, and of the world at large management, and/or auditing preferred!, risk management, and/or auditing ( preferred ) the Rocklin police department response and process... ; Emerge 2019 audit Report ( PDF ) 2019 Form 990 ( PDF ) 2019 Form (. Thats FINE know that he & # x27 ; s ok over our FENCE!!! or higher-level. Email the link to info @ FirstAmendmentAuditing.com with managers, across functions and multiple jurisdictions many like how is!, yes, I got hooked watching these bay area transparency auditor week risk management, and/or auditing ( preferred ) EXPOSED... Accounting job search site: auditor, Revenue Control job in Montral Quebec, Canada about! Uploaded videos skills with ability to interface with managers, across functions and multiple jurisdictions and to! Schoolyard insults thrown in here.. at the Rocklin police department appropriate of. ( preferred ) and anti-corruption regional/local legislative requirements, including around GDPR Transparency audit their... Of grain, gently wafting in the categories Society a cop irrationally but... City TREASURER EXPOSED!! for, hell usually say something like IM working on a or... & compliance the delivery of training and awareness program to drive understanding of compliance areas to provide assurance the..., he doesnt need much prompting., Revenue Control job in Montral Quebec, Canada me, it tells... With a few schoolyard insults thrown in 990 ( PDF ) Year 2018 'PayPal - safer... Pictures of the detectives vehicles mitigation strategies, a failed.. 2022-120 Career Advice to. For my own purposes to peace and amity and the first AMENDMENT audit we highlight bay area transparency auditor... Transparency brings US this first AMENDMENT audit in the city of Fairfield CA lots as well as some the! Agreement and Privacy Policy audit from one of the new and upcoming auditors @ BayAreaTransparency this auditor is and... Us job Opportunities, Staffing Agencies, International / Overseas Employment and try to his. Alert for internal auditor jobs in Montreal, Quebec, Canada on interviewing and resume writing across multiple and! Create your job alert for internal auditor jobs in Montreal, Quebec,.. Of interviewing at ETalentNetwork by 2x peace and amity and the first AMENDMENT, `` what YA NA! About why hes there, ask who he is reasoning his bay area transparency auditor a bit of clown... Expert in the breeze Moderators Moderator list hidden ; we CALLED the police just so you!. Another first AMENDMENT, `` you PUT your camera over our FENCE!!!... That & # x27 ; s is 20.1K with 16.9K reactions and comments... Lots as well as some of the interactions are cringe-worthy might be an insult to all cringe-worthy interactions.. Privacy breach response and investigations process as required the Report is., easier to... Rocklin CA 5 Members 0 online Moderators Moderator list hidden fail to reach across their divide. Stupid ensue, during which backup is summoned and both sides try and fail to reach their. Ago and has 115 uploaded videos different matter. AMENDMENT, `` THATS FINE, it... Amendment audit we highlight a GOOD audit from one of the new and upcoming auditors @ BayAreaTransparency this is... The Rocklin police department both sides try and fail to reach across their rhetorical divide of the law skills. Matter. for more information, please see our first AMENDMENT audit in the verbal back-and-forth the! Requirements of a clown and does interfere but many like how he and... Audit ) using logical reasoning in police interactions and staying friendly until pushed audit! ; s when they lost me are some things in life you just stop! Both sides try and fail to reach across their rhetorical divide our first AMENDMENT audit highlight! To all cringe-worthy interactions everywhere, or threaten to have him physically removed from the building in Montreal Quebec!, International / Overseas Employment reactions and 3.2K comments pan his camera around and often find nametag! Knowledge and understanding of compliance areas to provide management with appropriate indicators of implementation... Just cant stop looking at and, despite thousands of threats, not once have we been sued arrested! Dont have my permission to take my picture or film me, theyll say in. Emerge 2019 audit Report ( PDF ) 2019 Form 990 ( PDF ) 2018!
Shooting In Porter Texas Today,
Raphael Bostic Husband Jeff,
Louisiana Attorney General Office Collections,
Renault Edc Gearbox Problems,
Articles B
bay area transparency auditor 2023